latest changes & additions at abelard.org quotations at abelard.org, with source document where relevant link to short briefings documents link to document abstracts link to list of useful data tables click for abelard's child education zone Click for an introduction to cathedrals and stained glass in France. latest news headlines at abelard's news and comment zone socialism, sociology, supporting documents described economics and money zone at abelard.org - government swindles and how to transfer money on the net Energy - beyond fossil fuels visit abelard's gallery about abelard and abelard.org

back to abelard's front page

 France zone at abelard.org - another France

site map

lantern towers of normandy and elsewhere

related page:
gothic cathedral and church construction

Lantern at Evreux cathedral, 17th century engraving

   
 

france

cathedral labyrinths and mazes in France illustrated

Germans in France
Reims cathedral
Cambrai cathedral

Click to go to 'the highest, longest: the viaduct de Millau'

France’s western isles: Ile de Ré

Click to go to pages about Art Deco at abelard.org

on first arriving in France - driving

Click for motorways and motorway aires in France.

France is not England

Marianne - a French national symbol, with French definitive stamps

the calendar of the French Revolution

the 6th bridge at Rouen: Pont Gustave Flaubert,
new vertical lift bridge

Futuroscope

Vulcania

the French umbrella & Aurillac

the forest as seen by francois mauriac, and today pic

places and playtimepic

roundabout art of Les Landes

after the whirlwind, in les landes pic  pic

50 years old: Citroën DS

the Citroën 2CV:
a French motoring icon

la belle époque pic

 

Pic du Midi - observing stars clearly, A64 pic

Carcassonne, A61: world heritage fortified city pic

Grand Palais, Paris

Marianne - a French national symbol, with French definitive stamps

the calendar of the French Revolution

le pique-nique

Hermès scarves
Hèrmes logo

bastide towns

mardi gras! carnival in Basque country

what a hair cut! m & french pop/rock

country life in France: the poultry fair

Tour de France 2017

short biography of Pierre (Peter) Abelard

 

 

New translation, the Magna Carta

index
lantern-towers in normandy
putting a hat on it!
rouen lantern tower
other lantern tours in normandy
ely - a very special lantern
the spanish style
bibliography


Where the nave and transepts cross, that crossing can be surmounted by a dome or a tower, straddling the four corner pillars of the crossing.

Here are three forms of lantern tower,
at Coutances, Normandy in France - in stone
at Eely in Eastern England - in wood, and
at Burgos in Spain - a domed lantern, also called a cupola.

related pages:

lantern-towers in normandy

Where the nave and transept cross, Coutances Cathedral - looking up.
Looking up at where the nave and transept cross, Coutances Cathedral
Notice the two small balconies at levels 4 and 5 in the lantern tower - it's a long way up!
(See text for labelling information)

A crossing tower is usually built on the four main pillars at the intersection of the nave and the transept. If a tower is built, the four supporting pillars tend to be much more substantial than other pillars in the cathedral. This style seems to have been developed by the Normans, and there are several examples in the region of Normandy, including at Coutances, Evreux, Lisieux, Fecamp, and Rouen. The Normans won England in a card game, therefore you will find several lantern towers there, such as Bury St. Edmunds, Canterbury, Durham, Ely, Lincoln, Norwich, Peterborough, Salisbury, Wimborne Minister, York.

Various roofs, spires and glass insets can be seen in lantern and other towers. A lantern tower is only subject to wind loads, the buttressing within the cathedral is normally sufficient. Spire roof structures do not apply much outward pressures, as they are tied or pinned at their bases, as is done with cathedral forests. However, towers are subject to wind pressures.

Plan of Coutances cathedral
Plan of Coutances cathedral
Note the size of the pillar cross-section at nave-transept crossing

The lantern tower on Coutances cathedralWhen a gothic cathedral crossing tower is built, it is usually structurally four-sided, but sometimes is modified to other shapes. This was probably done for aesthetic reasons. An eight-sided lantern has its corners supported by pillars at the edge of the crossing. The intermediate corners may 'bend down' on arches between the pillars, or be supported on pillars, as at Ely. Coutances and Evreux have an octagonal lantern, whereas Fecamp and Rouen are of square cross-section. Countances is a considerable five-aisle, multi-level cathedral structure, and at the lantern-tower can be counted up to five levels, as is marked in the photo above. There, one of the massive pillars is marked twice with A. By comparison, Evreaux cathedral is quite a 'diddy' edifice.

Note that Fecamp is rated as an abbey, rather a full cathedral. Also there are other lantern-towers at Dijon and at Laon, if you are interested and going to the east and south of Paris.

If the tower has glassed openings that let in light down to the floor of the crossing, it is called a lantern or lantern tower. Because the crossing is without supporting walls, the weight of the tower or dome rests heavily on the supporting pillars which are often massive in order to hold the weight. Sometimes a church or cathedral lantern is called an illuminated tower or a drum.

Up in these towers, there are various scary, narrow, stone stairways, wooden ladders, and tight squeeze spaces for accessing the upper storeys and what the French call 'the attic'. The Coutances' lantern tower (illustrated on right) is eight-sided, flanked by four narrow staircase turrets with corkscrew stairs to access the roof. The access towers at Coutances are about 2 metres in diameter, so you can imagine the tightness of the spiral and the squeeze of these stairs. The tower-lantern may have been originally crowned with an spire that would have been higher than those of the west facade.

Sometimes the opening of the tower is smaller than the area of the crossing, or the tower has been 'octagonalised'. The smaller opening is supported and disguised by webs projecting out from the pillars. To make such a construction sufficiently strong and stable needs very capable builders. Several crossing towers collapsed in the past when ambition was greater than the builders' skills. One such collapse was at Ely cathedral in 1322.

putting a hat on it!

Raddon et Chapendue. Image: J. MassetA thousand years ago, towers in churches could be said to be rather ambiguous. Churches were multi- purpose, and one of those purposes was as a defensive refuge. hence, you will see many a church tower with Eglise de Lauredebattlements, arrow slits and other military appurtenances not entirely devoted to worship. Towers were also used as observation posts to provide warning against approaching pests. Even during World War One, the Germans used that excuse while shelling churches and cathedrals down the Western front. Their local artillery shelled the towers for practice, boredom and sheer bloody-mindedness.

Towers were often roofless, despite the nuisances of weather. But as humans became more wonderful and civilised and sweet, and even more wealthy, all manner of decorating went up on the towers as a form of weather-proofing and status proclamation.

Thus, all across France, towers have different decorations (roofing, spires...) on top. A great number of artistic and fanciful caps can be seen, as they try to be decorative or interesting. The Burgundy region, including Haute-Saône, is well-known for their fancy coloured tiling. Rouen cathedral's variation is its huge spire.

A collection of church hats (imperial-style roofs) in the Franche-Comté region. The link is to the first of twenty-odd pages.
[Here is the complete site plan for the church hat collection linked above (in French).]

 

 

 

 

 


advertising disclaimer

 


advertising disclaimer

 

 

 

 

Rouen lantern towerRouen cathedral

The central lantern tower, combined with its spire, is the tallest in France at 151m or 495 ft. Building started in the thirteenth century, the spire being raised in the sixteenth century. The present cast iron spire was raised in 1876 to replace the previous wooden spire, covered in gilded lead, which had been placed there in 1544. That wooden spire had been destroyed by fire in 1822.

From Rouen, It’s [sic] History and Monuments, A Guide to Strangers by Théodore Licquet, 1847, reprint 2007

“We cannot give too many praises to the zeal of M. de Vansay, prefect of the department at that time: the misfortune happened on the 15th september, and already on the 26th of the same month, the government having been informed and solicited by that magistrate, ordered M. Alavoine, one of the best architects, to go to Rouen, and confer with the prefect on the means of remedying the havoc caused by the fire. Early in the year 1823, the roofs of a aisles had already been repaired; and a portion of the nave had been covered with lead, by the 15th march of the same year. The roofs of the choir and of the whole transept, were also soon repaired; but, for these parts, a copper covering was preferred as being more solid and less liable to be destroyed. The raising and renewing the lantern was terminated in 1829.

“From this new platform, the pyramid will rise majestically in the air, and of it we already discover thirteen floors (the pyramid will be completed with one more), each of four metres fifty centimetres, that is to say a height of fifty eight metres, or about one hundred and eighty feet. The spire of the church was first erected of stone but was overthrown by the electric fluid, after that, it was twice built of wood, and both times it became the prey of the flames; to rebuild it with wood would have been gathering materials for a third fire, but now it is made of cast iron and in open work. At the summit of the spire, there will be a small lantern surrounded by a gallery for the purpose of meteorological observations. The total weight of the spire when completed, will be 600,000 kilogrammes, or about 1,200,000 pounds. It is composed of 2,540 pieces, not including 12,879 iron pins[13]. Lastly, this magnificent pyramid will reach an elevation of 436 feet; that is to say 40 feet higher than the former, and will only be 13 feet less than the highest pyramid of Egypt.

“[Footnote 13: The whole of these pieces of iron were cast at the foundry at Conches, a small town, which is situated at about twelve leagues from Rouen, and the expense is valued at 500,000 francs.]

Elise Whitlock Rose commented about the lantern tower:

"No truly artistic ideals disturbed the minds of the XIX century builders. They remembered only the perils of lightning and fire, and raised a spire which had every justification of sense and economy, but which, from an architectural point of view, is a hideous monstrosity. Unfortunately, it is of iron and will probably persist, to show to succeeding generations that the early XIX century was no less barbarous in its utilitarianism than the XVIII century was in its pseudo-classicism."
[p.353, Cathedrals and cloisters of the Isle de France, vol II by Elise Whitlock Rose]

 

some other lantern-towers in normandy

Lantern-tower, Evreux. Image: Jacques Mossot
Lantern-tower, Evreux (Normandie). Image: Jacques Mossot

Right : Lantern-tower, Laon (Aisne)

  Lantern-tower, Evreux. Image: Structurae - Jacques Mossot

Cathédrale Saint Pierre de Lisieux

Be careful not to confuse this 13th century, gothic cathedral with the modern, vulgar Christmas cake erected to Sainte Thérèse of Lisieux [1873-1897]. In fact, she attended the Norman cathedral with her parents. In the cathedral, the pews where Thérèse's family sat, at least in the past, were pointed out to visitors by church staff - I do not know whether this still occurs. Incidently, Thérèse's parents have also been recently sainted [2015]. Theresa was one of five sisters, who all became nuns.

The Christmas cake - the Basilique Sainte Thérèse de Lisieux [constructed 1929-1954] - was endowed with one of Thérèse's arms as a saint's relic by Pope Pius XI during its opening ceremony of the basilica. How he came by it I'm not certain.

 

ely - a very special lantern

Wooden skeleton of Ely cathedral lantern tower
Wooden skeleton of Ely cathedral lantern tower
[image : English cathedral carpentry]

A very special and unusual lantern can be seen at Ely, built after the collapse of the Norman lantern tower at Ely [Eely] in 1322. The repairs and development were made from around 1325 to 1340. The replacement was a very particular and new design built in wood by the brilliant carpenters of Merry England. It was rebuilt in its modern, truly impressive form under the supervision of Alan of Walsingham.

The structure is rather like a matchstick model, but on a greater scale, resting on and in the tower on corbels. Such a model can be surprisingly rigid and, of course, is far lighter then a stone tower. This is despite the matches being quite enormous compared with those you can buy at the Seven-Eleven.

The square-sectioned lantern-tower was supported by four pillars, which was replaced by the octagonal (eight-sided) lantern-tower is supported by eight pillars.

Diagram of Ely cathedral's pillar supports for previous and current lantern-towers
Diagram of Ely cathedral's pillar supports for previous and current lantern-towers

There guuided tours available for visitors to go into the galleries in the lantern-tour.

the spanish style

Notice the similarity of the dome lanterns below to lantern towers .

Domed lantern-tower at Valencia, Spain. Image: GFDL, sacred-destinations.com   Cupula de la capilla de los Condestables, Burgos Cathedral
Cupula de la capilla de los Condestables, Burgos Cathedral

Left : Domed lantern-tower at Valencia, Spain. Image: GFDL, sacred-destinations.com
 

bibliography

A Promise of Beauty: The Octagon Tower and Lantern at Ely Cathedral

A Promise of Beauty: The Octagon Tower and Lantern at Ely Cathedral
by Michael White

FrameCharge Press, 2007, pbk
ISBN-10: 0955577705
ISBN-13: 978-0955577703

amazon.com
amazon.co.uk


C.A. Hewett has put out three, steadily expanding versions of his book of cathedral carpentry.

  • English cathedral carpentry, 1974
  • English historic carpentry, 1980
  • English cathedral and monastic carpentry, 1985

A life's enthusiasm.

A rough outline can presently be found here:
Wooden Octagonal Lantern Tower of Ely Cathedral
[C.A. Hewett, English Cathedral Carpentry (London, 1974), pp. 82-9]


La cathédrale de Coutances

La cathédrale de Coutances
by Patrice Colmet Daage

 H. Laurens, 2nd edition, 1967, pbk
ASIN: B003WR78GW

amazon.com
amazon.co.uk


L'Eglise de la Trinité de Fécamp by J Vallery-Radot

L'Eglise de la Trinité de Fécamp
by Jean Vallery-Radot

H. Laurens, 1991, pbk

ISBN-10: 2862681016
ISBN-13: 978-2862681016

amazon.com
amazon.co.uk

 

L'Eglise de la Trinité de Fécamp by J Vallery-Radot

La Cathédrale d'Evreux
by G. Bonnenfant

Henri Laurens, Paris, pbk, approx. 1900s

(series: Petites monographies des grands édifices de la France)

 

L'Eglise de la Trinité de Fécamp by J Vallery-Radot

La Cathédrale de Rouen
by Armand Loisel

Henri Laurens, Paris, pbk, approx. 1900s

(series: Petites monographies des grands édifices de la France)

 
 
marker cathedrals – introduction: reading stained glass
marker gothic cathedral and church construction
marker lantern towers of Normandy and elsewhere
marker cathedrals, an illustrated glossary
marker Chartres - wonder of the world
marker history of ugly stained glass: Auch, Bazas, Dreux
marker Auch cathedral choir and stalls
marker Rouen and Monet
marker at France pages Dax and church iconography marker photographs, Dax
marker Bazas - iconography and architectural styles
marker Poitiers, neglected masterpiece marker photographs, Poitiers / photos 2
marker Angers, heart of the Angevin Empire marker photographs, Angers
marker Laon, the midst of the gothic transition, with added oxen marker photographs, Laon
marker Saint-Jean-Baptiste de Lyon
marker Notre Dame of Lausanne
marker Senlis - how a typical cathedral changes through the ages
marker Saint-Bertrand-de-Comminges - the cathedral of the Pyrenees
marker Le Mans and Bourges cathedrals - medieval space technology
marker Lausanne rose window - photo-analysis
marker cathedrals in Lorraine - the Three Bishoprics
marker cathedral giants - Amiens and Beauvais
marker Clermont-Ferrand and Agde - from volcanoes to cathedrals

marker Germans in France - Arras cathedral
marker Germans in France - Reims cathedral
marker Germans in France - St. Quentin cathedral
marker Germans in France - Noyon cathedral
marker Germans in France - Cambrai cathedral
marker Germans in France - Soissons cathedral

marker cathedral plans, and facts
marker using metal in gothic cathedral construction illustrated
marker cathedral labyrinths and mazes in France illustrated
marker cathedrals and cloisters of France by Elise Whitlock Rose

abstracts briefings information headlines   loud music & hearing damage children & television violence what is memory, and intelligence? about abelard

email abelard@abelard.org

© abelard, 2017, 7 july


all rights reserved

the address for this document is http://www.abelard.org/france/lantern-towers-normandy-and-elsewhere.php

2060 words
prints as 7 A4 pages (on my printer and set-up)