latest changes & additions at abelard.org quotations at abelard.org, with source document where relevant link to short briefings documents link to document abstracts link to list of useful data tables click for abelard's child education zone economics and money zone at abelard.org - government swindles and how to transfer money on the net latest news headlines at abelard's news and comment zone socialism, sociology, supporting documents described France zone at abelard.org - another France Energy - beyond fossil fuels visit abelard's gallery about abelard and abelard.org

New translation, the Magna Carta

sociology - the structure of analysing belief systems

co-operation and being nice

suckers, grudgers and cheats

chapter 1, herds and the individual - sociology, the ephemeral nature of groups
chapter 2, counting beliefs - irrational associations
chapter 3, logicians, 'logic' and madness
chapter 4, intelligence and madness
chapter 5, irrational actions - analysis of behaviour
chapter 6, co-operation and being nice
chapter 7, the problem of moderation

back to abelard's front page

site map

 
co-operation and being nice - suckers, grudgers and cheats is part of sociology - the structure of analysing belief systems.

on sociology on socialism 'social' economics supporting resources
and background documents
For more on sociology and socialism:

Introdution - socialism & sociology
sociology - the structure of analysing belief systems

Labour Party pamphlets:

 

And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors.
Matthew 6:12 (King James version)

introduction
suckers, grudgers and cheats
end notes
bibliography

introduction

During the 1980s, various models of hypothetical populations started to be run as simulations on computers. One useful way of classifying the way members of a society interact with each other is by sorting them into suckers, grudgers or cheats. This is a classification after Maynard Smith, popularised by Richard Dawkins in his book The Selfish Gene pp.184-185, built on watching grooming behaviour of birds carrying harmful parasites.

These were birds that helped each other in an apparently altruistic way, but refused to help - bore a grudge against - individuals that had previously refused to help them. Grudgers came to dominate the population because they passed on more genes to future generations than either Suckers (who helped others indiscriminately, and were exploited) or Cheats (who tried ruthlessly to exploit everybody, and ended up doing each other down).

Notice that such strategies depend heavily upon individuals being able to recognise other individuals apart, and to remember the individual and its/their behaviour. This has obvious and different implications for those living in small villages and groups contra those living in large and somewhat anonymous cities.

suckers, grudgers and cheats

Imagine a population of creatures that has three varieties of individuals: suckers, cheats, and grudgers.

At first, all of these individuals co-exist in equal numbers, but eventually the number of grudgers will increase until they dominate the population. This occurs for a number of reasons.

  • Suckers end up helping everyone indiscriminately and they end up being exploited shamelessly by others.
  • Cheats take as much as they can get from everyone and rarely reciprocate anything. The “cheat” strategy is profitable for a while, but as the number of suckers diminish and as the cheats are found out, they become less successful.
  • The hardiest survivors are the grudgers, who continue to help those who help them but refuse to cooperate with cheats.
  • The cheats first eliminate the suckers, but they in turn are then eliminated by the grudgers.

Hence, even though an altruistic behaviour being performed in the present may prove beneficial to only one of the individuals involved, under a system of reciprocal altruism the other person will eventually be repaid in kind.

We saw how, in the example of mutual grooming, if there are only suckers and cheats around, the strategy Cheat is evolutionarily stable, while the strategy Sucker is not. Now introduce a third strategy, Grudger.

A grudger is rather like you and me. A grudger grooms anyone who has previously groomed him, and any stranger, but he remembers and bears a grudge against anyone who cheats him - who refuses to groom him in return for having been groomed - and the grudger refuses to groom the cheat ever again. Now when all three strategies are in play, both Cheat and Grudger are evolutionarily stable. In a population consisting largely of cheats, the cheats will do better than the others, and both suckers and grudgers will die out. But in a population that starts off with more than a critical proportion of grudgers, the cheats will first wipe out the suckers, but will then themselves become rare and eventually extinct: Cheats can flourish only while they have suckers to take advantage of, and yet by doing so, they tend to eliminate those suckers.

It is obvious, by the way, that a population containing only suckers and grudgers, in any proportions, but no cheats, would simply continue as it was. Suckers and grudgers behave exactly like one another as long as there are no cheats around, so there would be no tendency for either the Sucker of the Grudger gene to do better than the other. But if there is any risk of an invasion of Cheat genes, either through mutation or through immigration, such a pattern is not evolutionarily stable, and the higher the proportion of suckers, the more rapidly the cheats would multiply.

Another name for grudgers is ‘reciprocal altruists’. They act as if on the maxim ‘Be done by as you did’, also see 'tit for tat' in The Evolution of Cooperation (see especially pp. 27-54). One implication of this story is that this strategy is not only evolutionarily stable within a population, it is also viable for a population as a whole. The explanation of the final situation, where all birds of this species are grudgers, lies partly in the non-viability of a population of pure cheats.

now read
chapter 7, the problem of moderation

 

For further reading:    
marker and then there were none – eric frank russell, 1951

lozenge feed back and crowding
marker ends and means and the individual lozenge herds and the individual - sociology, the ephemeral nature of groups

end notes

  1. A word of warning. All such simulations are crude simplifications of the real world. Various game-playing models have been run competitively against other attempts, and it is found that 'nice' tend to defeat 'nasty' models of co-operation or defection.

    This can be seen in paranoid behaviour, which tends to evoke aggression in others. The paranoic, being distrustful, behaves in a negative manner to other people. This tends to evoke negative behaviour in others, thus reinforcing the original paranoia. So being nice tends to be a winning strategy, whereas being nasty, in general terms, tend to be a loosing strategy. Even forgiveness, up to a point, is likely to improve your relationships and your society.

    Machiavelli advises the Prince, "Do not do small harms to people, but if you are going to do harm, do great harm whereby the opponent is no longer in a position to harm you." In other words, to kill them. This is not a strategy which tends to develop successful and happy societies as you can note from observing dictatorships and dictators, or even the lives of lower-scale murderers and violent people.

  2. tit for tat
    Tit-for-tat is an attempt to model a part of human behaviour. Human behaviour is far more complex than a model suggests. This sort of modelling is sometimes applied to a problem situation known as the prisoner's dilemma. A common example is when police try to get two or more 'suspects' to each rat out on the other/s. The police may promise each person their freedom if they are the first to rat out, while threatening that if another suspect can rat them out first, it is the current interviewee who risks a ten-year sentence. Of course, this puts great pressure on people to fit up one another, the objective of the police. This ploy is often called 'plea bargaining', and clearly is a very dangerous practice.

    In modelling,the actual numbers in the the table try to define the relative pay-offs for the prisoners (suspects). Here is a typical pay-off table:
    the prisoner's dilemma
        column player
        co-operate defect
    row player co-operate R=3, R=3
    Reward for mutual
    co-operation
    S=0, T=5
    Sucker's payoff, and
    Temptation to defect.
    defect T=5, S=0
    Temptation to defect, and
    Sucker's payoff
    P=1, P=1
    Punishment for
    mutual defection

    A tit-for-tat operator always starts by co-operating. When an entity does something/not liked/unpleasant/costly to another (tat), the other person/recipient then does the same action back (tit). That is the end of the incident.

    If the actions continue, the process can be called a blood feud.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


advertising disclaimer

 

 

bibliography

The Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins

Dawkins, Richard 
The Selfish Gene
Oxford University Press, 2006, 3rd rev. edn, 0199291152, pbk
$9.98 [amazon.com] / £5.39 [amazon.co.uk]

A useful popularisation of modern ideas concerning the propagation and survival of genes. The second edition is more tightly written than the first. Dawkins’ Climbing Mount Improbable is a useful adjunct. I would advise reading both these books in context, with other books in this section and Axlerod’s Evolution of Co-operation (details below). It is very easy to draw too simplistic an understanding of the evolutionary model.
See also
memes.


image credit: amazon.co.uk

Axelrod, Robert
The Evolution of Cooperation

(pbk, 1985, Basic Books, 0465021212
$21 [amazon.com] / £16.99 [amazon.co.uk]

Essential reading for all libertarians


The Prince by Machiavelli

Machiavelli, Niccolo
The Prince

For a more realistic understanding of human society. A must read for any aware individual.

The Prince by Machiavelli

AmazonClassics, 2017, pbk

ISBN-10: 1542047544
ISBN-13: 978-1542047548

$5.99 [amazon.com]

Kindle edition

AmazonClassics, 2017
File Size: 1547 KB
ASIN: B072M4TTGY

$0.00 [amazon.com]
£0.00 [amazon.co.uk]

Clydesdale Press, 2017, pbk

ISBN-10: 1945186267
ISBN-13: 978-1945186264

£3.92 [amazon.co.uk]

You are here: co-operation and being nice - suckers, grudgers and cheats < briefings documents < Home

email abelard email abelard at abelard.org

© abelard, 2017, 21 june

all rights reserved

the address for this document is https://www.abelard.org/briefings/sucker_grudger_cheat.php

1500 words
prints as 3 A4 pages (on my printer and set-up)

latest abstracts information quotations   headlines resources interesting about abelard